Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you select links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Dont sleep on this underrated appliance.
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
This versatile appliance typically beats a traditional oven in speed and convenience, and often doubles as anair fryeranddehydrator.
To find the best toaster ovens on the market, we researched and tested several models right at home.
To learn more about how we tested toaster ovens, check outour testing processbelow.
Credit: Amazon
The heating element is powerful, which can lead to overcooked food.
The capacity is impressive.
We fit up to nine cookies or slices of toast inside during testing.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
The dials and controls are very easy to read, especially with the light-up panel.
A powerful heating element is both a pro and con.
Because of its petite size, it has small dials and a somewhat cramped interior.
The Black + Decker oven comes with four standard functions: bake, broil, toast, and warm.
Also note that the top gets very hot while in use.
The displayed temperature was sometimes inconsistent with the actual temperature.
The Breville Smart Oven has more features and functions11 totalthan almost any other appliance we tested.
Theres even a frozen foods button that adds the recommended defrosting time to the timer.
We were able to fit six cookies in the oven to bake, and they came out very well.
We found a 10-degree fluctuation at the maximum temperature.
The fries we made in the air fryer basket came out flawlessly crisp.
The included rotisserie spit, setting screws, forks, and cooking pan are also standout additions.
Using an oven thermometer, we found a 10-degree fluctuation when we set the toaster at the maximum temperature.
While all accessories aredishwasher safe, they do need to be disassembled when possible before cleaning.
The heat map was inconsistent while toasting and baking.
The features included in this Breville toaster oven make it one of the best weve tried.
The dials and buttons are also sleek and intuitive.
It shone on the broiling setting, resulting in impeccably melted cheese.
Credit: Amazon
There is no indication of whether these pieces are dishwasher safe, so we suggest handwashing to be cautious.
If youreshort on spaceor are more of a casual cook, this pick is worth serious consideration.
When tested, the toaster ovens temperature came in at much higher than it should have been.
Credit: Amazon
If youre not much of a cook, this user-friendly option will quickly build yourconfidence in the kitchen.
The instruction booklet includes tons of recipes and a reference guide with the proper cook times for common ingredients.
Theres also a backlit screen controlled by a dial knob that allows you to select your cooking function.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Though there is a countdown timer once you pick the function, theres no timer dial.
The instructions also specifically advise you to wipe down the top after cookinggreasy foods.
The air fryer warms the food as needed but doesnt provide a consistent crisp.
This model lost some points in the air frying department.
When used according to directions, some of the fries came out soggy while the others were too crispy.
Its also worth pointing out that the air fryer setting is a bit noisy.
All the pieces are removable and should be hand washed with soap and water.
We werent able to use a 9x13-inch pan in the oven.
The toaster oven is offered in six colors and features a gold handle for a luxe look.
Theres a touch-activated display that makes it easy to use.
This toaster oven comes with an air frying basket, bake pan, and wire rack.
We found the air frying basket difficult to insert, but loved the removable crumb tray for easy cleanup.
Plus its worth noting that while some inserts are dishwasher-safe, others require hand washing.
This ovens large size and heat emission limit counter placement.
The toaster ovens large capacity accommodates a variety of foods, like a whole chicken and a 12-inch pizza.
The top rapid oven options include bake, broil, reheat, keep warm, bagel, and toast.
The accessory trays felt unsteady and did not fit securely.
The Our Place Wonder Oven is popular for its beautiful design and effective performance.
Credit: Amazon
The compact design was also quite easy to use during testing, making it one of our top picks.
Accessories include a wire rack, bake pan, air fryer basket, and crumb tray.
That being said, the toast oven quickly preheats, saving time while cooking.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
We purchased a mat to put underneath the toaster oven to protect our quartz counters.
In addition to 11 cooking parameters, this toaster oven doesnt require any preheating before use.
Overall, we liked the sleek look of this toaster oven.
This unit features a digital display that makes it easy to choose which function you want to use.
We noted that this unit is very quiet while cooking and only beeps when the food is done cooking.
Since this toaster oven doesnt require any preheating, it worked quicker than our standard oven.
When it comes to this toaster oven, our only concern was our quartz countertops.
We were impressed with its large capacity, versatile functions, and consistent results.
These scores were then combined to determine an average rating for each toaster oven.
We looked at the control panels presets and functions, as well as the included accessories.
To test performance, we compared the displayed temperature with the true temperature inside the oven using a thermometer.
If the toaster oven had an air fryer function, we also made fries.
Credit: Amazon
To judge the value, we compared our ratings against the price.
Unlike a lot of appliances, a toaster oven cant be pushed against the wall when in use.
Standard functions include toast, bake, and broil.
Credit: Amazon
The baking feature was especially successful, resulting in evenly baked cookies.
Your Questions, Answered
What features should I look for in a toaster oven?
Standard toaster oven features include toasting, baking, and broiling.
Credit: Amazon
Several of our favorites also feature air fryers, pizza/bagel configs, dehydrating capabilities, and more.
You should aim for non-stick and enameled accessories when possible, as theyre easier to clean.
Is an air fryer better than a convection toaster oven?
Credit: Walmart
Can a toaster oven replace an oven?
While Bisiotis says a toaster oven cant necessarilyreplace a full-size oven, the right onecando a lot.
During our tests, we toasted bread, baked cookies, made fries, and broiled gooey melted cheese.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
She also consulted chefChristos Bisiotis, owner of the hospitality company The CB Concepts, for additional insights.
BHG contributorJordan Liberty Phillipsupdated this article.
Her expertise includes recipes and cooking, home decor, and shopping.
What Is BHG Recommends?
Next to all of the products on this list, you may have noticed ourBHG Recommends seal of approval.
In these cases, we use the same testing criteria we use to test the purchased products.
Looking for more products that have earned ourBHG Recommends seal of approval?
Check out our picks for everything from picnic blankets to humidifiers.
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
