Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you press links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Then, we rated each roasting pan based ondesign,performance, andease of cleaning.
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
For more information on how we tested these pans, check outour lab testing processbelow.
It can be heavy when loaded with large cuts of meat.
It also features easy to-grasp handles for lifting the pan with oven mitts on.
Credit: Williams Sonoma
Plus, a nonreactive cooking surface also makes it excellent for prepping stovetop gravies and sauces.
The pan offers adequate size and depth, with a capacity that holds up to 20 pounds.
During testing, we noticed the pan was a bit heavy when fully loaded with large cuts of meat.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens / Sarah Martens
For best results, a nylon scrubbing pad and fine-powdered cleanser are recommended.
While it isnt lightweight, its built to last if cared for properly.
Its a bit smaller than other roasting pans on our list.
For those looking for an affordable roasting pan, this is the best option for you.
The groove around the edge catches drippings, but also limits the amount youll have for that tasty gravy.
During our testing, we found that this pan roasted a bird thoroughly after about an hour.
We were able to fit potatoes under the rack, but it was a tight fit.
However, this roasting pan yielded delicious potatoes that were caramelized and buttery.
Because the potatoes were slightly overcooked, the cleanup process was a little tedious.
If youre looking for astainless steeloption, this is the best stainless steel roasting pan we tested.
This pan roasted a perfect, evenly browned chicken.
We also like that it has a convenient pouring rim that prevents drips, too.
Because the potatoes got overcooked during testing, we found thatcleaning the stainless steel panrequired some effort and scrubbing.
The chicken slid around slightly on the rack.
After about 15 minutes, the potatoes looked brown and started to caramelize.
The gravy was smooth and well-incorporated.
Because of this, we gave it a 5 out of 5 star rating for ease of cleaning.
This meant that once the roast was added, we noticed that it did slide around a bit.
It can also be used on gas and electric stovetops.
It was a little difficult to get the drippings out to make gravy.
All of the potatoes were perfectly creamy on the inside, however.
However, nylon scrubbing pads are fine to use.
It arrives in somewhat challenging packaging, with a sticker thats difficult to remove.
During testing, we were impressed with the pans results across the board.
It can also be washed in the dishwasher, making cleanup easy and convenient.
The only disappointment with this roaster was a sticker that was difficult to remove when we first unboxed it.
It is very heavy and can be a challenge to clean.
Its versatile enough to roast meats and vegetables, bake casseroles and desserts, and make stovetop sauces.
During testing, we found that it roasted chicken and vegetables perfectly.
After roasting the chicken and potatoes, we reserved the drippings to make gravy.
For design, we looked closely at each pans shape, capacity, materials, and features like handles.
Since oven sizes can vary, be sure your roasting pan will fit easily into your oven.
There are even petite-sized roasting pans for some countertop ovens, saysArt Jackson, co-founder of Pleasant House Pub.
Im a stainless steel fan.
I think for the casual home cook, it is versatile and easier to maintain, he says.
It can take a beating and be brand new for the next use.
Credit: Amazon
While a rack isnt necessarily imperative, it does have its benefits in a roasting pan.
It also helps with airflow which promotes even roasting.
Plenty of roasting pans dont come with lids and they get the job done without them.
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Handles can add helpful lifting assistance and portability when needed.
If you entertain often, a dishwasher-safe pick is one less thing to worry about when you clean.
We found the nonstick surface to be especially effective.
Considering the steep price tag, it underperformed and did not earn our recommendation.
We felt it would be best used for making sheet pan dinners or roasted vegetablesbut probably not meat roasts.
Its oven-safe up to 450F and has a nonstick, easy-to-clean surface.
However, the chicken didnt cook evenly and the potatoes ended up mostly overcooked.
This roasting pan also isnt dishwasher safe.
Because of its poor performance, it earned low scores throughout our testing.
Your Questions, Answered
Is stainless steel or aluminum better for a roasting pan?
Aluminum is a great heat conductor and is lightweight and relatively inexpensive.
It also distributes heat evenly and is easy to clean when used properly.
Should roasting pans have deep or shallow sides?
This is mostly a matter of preference and depends on what kind of food youll be roasting.
Does a roasting pan need a rack?
Not every roasting pan comes with a rack, though its definitely a key detail to consider.
Most chefs do tend to prefer one when available.
This lower layer will help keep whatever youre roasting off the bottom of the pan.
BHG contributorJordan Liberty Phillipsalso updated this article.
Her expertise includes recipes and cooking, home decor, and shopping.
In these cases, we use the same testing criteria we use to test the purchased products.
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens / Russell Kilgore
Credit: Target
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens / Russell Kilgore
Credit: Amazon
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens / Alan Schultz
Credit: Amazon
Credit: Better Homes & Gardens / Erin Hooker
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
